Welcome to World Footy News
Tuesday, May 11 2021 @ 09:59 am ACST

Irish Hawk Raises Solid Point



As a kid in the Aussie Rules playing states of Australia, from the first time you pick up a footy and kick it around the yard you are on the path to AFL football. From the youngest ages, Auskick programs, junior clubs, representative football, school football and later academies and combines create a path to the big time. The pathways are clear and ready.


Not so in Ireland. At least not as directly for Australian Football. The equivalent local pathways can take young Irish kids on a journey to club, county and country Gaelic football. But whilst on that journey, many kids – girls and boys – might learn of an opportunity to head to Australia and try AFL. Be the next Jim Stynes or Tadgh Kennelly. At this point. Careers do a complete right angled turn and Irish clubs face the prospect of losing their talent to another code – albeit related.

 As men and women reach the stage of heading down under, the clubs in Ireland simply rebuild by growing the next talent – and then possibly losing them also. In the vast majority of cases these clubs do all they can to help their talented players live a dream. Bu it doesn’t necessarily help the clubs – even though they are given a small level of compensation from the AFL.   

Irish Hawk, Conor Nash, has raised the issue as the Irish clubs being far better compensated for grooming talent which they lose to Australian clubs. His views can be found in an article on the www.afl.com.au website, and appears here in part to provide the basis of his argument. 

IRISH Hawthorn forward Conor Nash has backed calls for Gaelic football clubs that have players poached by AFL teams to be fairly compensated.

North Melbourne's recruitment of Red Óg Murphy late last month brought the number of listed Irish players in the AFL to a record 14.  

Nash told the We Are Meath podcast in Ireland that Gaelic clubs deserved payment after developing young prospects. 

"I certainly think there is a case there for some sort of compensation. It certainly has to be the club. I wouldn't think it would be the county board or something like that," Nash said.

"If it was the club, yes, I'd be all for that. If it was the county board as such, probably not. 

"I'd love to see it go back right to the roots, because everybody knows that clubs could do with a bit of spare cash every now and then." 

However, Nash pointed out a potential complexity with such a system. 

"If you look at my situation where I (played Gaelic) football and rugby, do you compensate both of themω Do you compensate one more than the otherω" Nash said. 

Compensation does exist in small doses – linked in part to a games played formula. But many AFL clubs are getting great talent for a relative pittance. If the AFL clubs can demand massive draft selection benefits for losing players to free agency, then surely clubs that produce the likes of Nash, teammate Conor Glass, Essendon’s Conor McKenna, Suns’ star Pearce Hanley, Cat Zach Tuohy and Sydney Swan Colin O’Riordan deserve a little more respect (and due compensation) for providing such a talent and aiding them in getting to AFL list.  

To put things in a slightly unfair light, the Western Bulldogs lost Luke Dalhaus and were give draft pick #25 as compensation. Collingwood lost Alex Fasolo and got pick #57. Did the Irish clubs who lost players over the past 12 months or so receive anything remotely comparable for giving up potential starsω No, it certainly isn’t the same thing – but it does involve clubs losing talent. 

The AFL and its 18 clubs have money. They can afford to do something more to develop the game back in Ireland. It is only a matter of enough people agreeing that they should, then put things in place. In return, the talent pool from Ireland will likely grow further. It has grown substantially over the past ten years and will grow further over the next ten – and AFL clubs are the biggest beneficiaries of that growth. 

But Conor Nash has raised a pertinent issue, and one that might be cause for a very healthy debate – both in Ireland and here in Australia.

To read Dinny Navaratnam’s full story on the AFL website, go to: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-11-14/afl-teams-should-compensate-gaelic-clubs-says-irish-hawk

  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Twitter
  • SlashDot
  • Del.icio.us
  • Yahoo Buzz

Story Options

Irish Hawk Raises Solid Point | 3 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Irish Hawk Raises Solid Point
Authored by: Harley Vague on Thursday, November 15 2018 @ 01:35 pm ACDT

Solid point ?????? You do realise that the AFL does not compensate any Australian football clubs that produce AFL players.You do realise that the AFL has decimated state leagues by not compensating any Australian football clubs. Why would you want help a rival code over your own code FFS ? For the amount of outlay these combines are NOT producing any great numbers. the money could be better spent elsewhere. If the GAA don't like it then stuff it. The GAA don't do anything to help promote their own game. GAA players lose NOTHING because they are not paid.You want to give money to clubs that perpetuate this feudal system? The AFL and now the AFLW are giving people overseas a great opportunity - a great financial opportunity as well. The AFL clubs have already given Irish players an unique concession and that is to play GAA in the off season. We in Australia are starved of S.O.O. and sometimes IR because AFL clubs won't release their players for fear of injury.
Rugby and the EPL don't compensate the GAA. The NFL doesn't compensate the AFL for recruiting punters. The AFL and NRL don't compensate each other for taking players.
IMO Gaelic Football would be the best code for an entrepreneur to take to the world - rectangular field, round ball, no tackling, many options and lots of action, yet the Irish languish in melancholy and tradition rather than produce an action plan. The Irish have a great code and could benefit greatly by working with Australian Football rather than working against.

Irish Hawk Raises Solid Point
Authored by: Wesley Hull on Friday, November 16 2018 @ 02:09 pm ACDT

Yes, his point is solid. It is based on his far more direct connection to the game back in Ireland - he is in a position to understand what is going on back there than we are. It is a SOLID point. But that doesn't make it right or wrong. I hear your argument, Harley, and in many ways agree.

But this isn't just about Irish players seeking opportunity. This is also about the AFL having identified a new talent pool and they should not be using it as one way traffic to benefit AFL clubs and not suitably assisting that nursery. Whether they help Gaelic football directly, or just offer more to AFL Ireland as a more localised pathway, the AFL still needs to invest in grass roots fairly. This is where the debate will be - are they or are they not investing what they should to grow this market.

Some will say yes, some will say no - but that's what a good, healthy debate is all about.

Irish Hawk Raises Solid Point
Authored by: Harley Vague on Friday, November 16 2018 @ 03:15 pm ACDT

The AFL is simply buying players. End of story.
The AFL is doing the GAA a gigantic favour. They might consider paying their players now and end the feudal system that is their football a.t.m.