Thursday, May 08 2008 @ 12:55 PM EST
Contributed by: Chris Adams
WorldFootyNews.com and USFootyNews.com have once again combined to produce the second USFooty Top 10 Poll of 2008. The San Diego Lions have regained first place after losing to Denver in the 2007 National Championship game, perhaps proving that no news is good news.
It's still very early in the season for most United States clubs. San Diego is yet to play a game for 2008 and they face the Las Vegas Gamblers in Vegas at the end of the month. The Baltimore Washington Eagles (4-0) gained a place after taking the Faststream Invitational in Florida against Denver, New York and Florida. The Denver Bulldogs (0-3) dropped from first to third after finishing fourth in the Faststream Invitational. The New York Magpies (2-1) remained at fourth after coming in second in Florida. Golden Gate remained at fifth and plays its first game at the end of the month when it heads down to LA to take on the Number 7 Orange County Bombers.
Minnesota stay at sixth and heads down to St Louis on the 17th for their debut in the MAAFL Championship League. The Orange County Bombers (0-1) remained at 7th after losing to the Dallas Magpies on the road. Seattle Grizzlies (0-1) moved to 8th despite losing on the road to Portland Power. The Atlanta Kookaburras (3-0) moved into the Top 10 at 9th with wins against Florida, Baton Rouge and Nashville. The Dallas Magpies (1-0) round out the Top 10 after defeating the OC Bombers in Dallas.
The poll is designed to give an indication of the best teams in the US, given that with multiple leagues across the country it's difficult to statistically rank sides, at least until Nationals at year's end.
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
2008 WFN/USFN USFooty Poll Number 2
Authored by: Dingo on
Thursday, May 08 2008 @ 07:26 PM EST
I have no idea what this poll means - I know this isn't the first one that has been up on WFN. What is it basically a ranking system of the top 10 teams in the US?
To be honest I think it is a spurious article with no real relevance to USFooty and definitely none to international footy. It's only interesting to the people that play on the teams. This article should surely be limited to the USFooty website.
Authored by: Brett on
Friday, May 09 2008 @ 01:34 PM EST
I understand the gist of what you're saying Dingo, in that the specifics of which club in the US is ranked higher than another, might be mainly of interest to followers of the US league, but this site is about all footy and people can read what they want and skip the rest. Likewise someone say in Asia might not be that interested in how the Irish league is going. People like myself that have an interest in all areas of footy are probably in the minority. Neverthless, we report across the spectrum. We certainly don't limit ourselves to stories that apply to every country.
As for the legitimacy of the poll itself, I can understand if some people might feel that it's a bit contrived since it's a matter of opinion. But unlike quite a few countries where there's one clearly top league, the US is a big country with a lot of leagues so it is nice now and then to consider how the different top clubs are going.
I suspect that given its controversial nature, the modest size of the audience that may be really keen to see the results, the amount of effort that Chris puts into gathering the poll (quite a lot I'd imagine) and the relatively small number of games on which to judge form, I'd probably recommend that just doing a mid-season and end-of-season poll would probably be plenty. But that's really up to Chris. We certainly welcome his continued support of worldfootynews.com since he began his focus on the usfootynews.com site.
--- Brett Northey - Co-founder and Chief Editor of WFN
Authored by: Chris Adams on
Friday, May 09 2008 @ 10:42 PM EST
For the Australians or Europeans a poll like this may seem strange, but they are ubiquitous in American sport. One of the biggest sports in the USA, College Football runs two polls every week and these polls more or less determine the National Champion. But there are also polls in many other sports including high school football, both at the National level and regional level. For example the Washington Post runs a poll for the top 25 high school football teams in the Washington area. If you are looking for an alternative, more traditional ranking of US teams, go to the USFooty Ladder (http://www.usfootynews.com/content/view/79/144/). Finally, I note that while this poll is not official the top 8 teams from last poll before the Nationals were the 8 teams selected into Division 1 and the top 2 teams played in the National Championship game.
To be honest I think it is a spurious article with no real relevance to USFooty and definitely none to international footy. It's only interesting to the people that play on the teams. This article should surely be limited to the USFooty website.
my two cents...
---
John Enright
http://www.arfli.com